Oneassure

Partner with us

Insurance Plans Comparison

HDFC ERGO Optima Secure vs ICICI Lombard Criti Shield Family Shield

Make an informed decision with our detailed side-by-side comparison of top health insurance policies. Compare...

Read more
HDFC ERGO

Optima Secure

Get up to 4X coverage with built-in benefits that increase your cover, restore your sum insured and protect you against specified non-medical hospital expenses.

What Makes It Special:

HDFC ERGO Optima Secure is a comprehensive health insurance plan offering coverage from ₹5 lakh to ₹2 crore for individuals and families. It provides a Secure Benefit that doubles your coverage from day one, Plus Benefit that grows it further on renewal, and Restore Benefit that reinstates the base sum after a...

Best For:

  • Comprehensive Family Health Insurance

  • Multi-Benefit Medical Protection Plan

  • Coverage with Automatic Sum Boost

  • Restoration-enabled Secure Health Policy

VS
ICICI Lombard

Criti Shield Family Shield

Cover hospitalisation for specified infectious diseases, including listed vector-borne illnesses such as dengue and malaria, and personal accident benefits for death, disablement and accidental hospital treatment.

What Makes It Special:

ICICI Lombard Family Shield combines defined benefits for specified infectious diseases with personal accident and hospital daily cash benefits. Coverage includes selected vector-borne, viral, gastrointestinal and nervous system infections, along with rabies and tetanus. Additional benefits may be available depending on the options selected and the policy certificate.

Best For:

  • Customers who understand that this is a benefit-specific policy and not a substitute for comprehensive hospitalisation insurance.

  • Buyers who want to explore optional benefits such as broken bones or burns cover.

  • People who value fixed hospital daily cash benefits where selected.

  • Families seeking additional financial protection against eligible accidental injuries.

  • Buyers looking for defined benefits for specified infectious diseases.

Insurance Plans Comparison

Get Personalized Advice

Our insurance experts are here to help you make the right choice. Get personalized recommendations based on your specific needs and budget.

Quick Decision Guide

HDFC ERGO Optima Secure

  • Coverage growth with Secure and Plus Benefits

  • Automatic sum insured restoration after claims

  • No room-rent or ICU restrictions

  • Annual health check-ups and preventive care

  • Long-term loyalty rewards and discounts

ICICI Lombard Criti Shield Family Shield

  • If you need broad coverage for unrelated illnesses, surgeries and hospital bills, compare this policy with a comprehensive indemnity-based health insurance plan.

  • Review waiting periods carefully, particularly the 30-day waiting period for infectious disease benefits and the pre-existing disease restriction applicable to hospital daily cash benefits.

  • Review the personal accident benefit amounts and definitions of disability before relying on the policy for accident protection.

  • Confirm whether hospital daily cash benefits are included and check the applicable daily limits and eligibility conditions.

  • Check the list of covered infections and their claim requirements to confirm that the policy addresses your priorities.

Insurance Plans Comparison

Detailed Features Comparison

Compare the key features of different health insurance plans

Optima Secure
Optima Secure

Health Insurance Plan

Brochure

Policy Wording

VS
Criti Shield Family Shield
Criti Shield Family Shield

Health Insurance Plan

Brochure

Policy Wording

Room Rent

Optima Secure

All room categories are covered

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

  1. Normal: Covered Up to Sum Insured
  2. ICU: Covered Up to Sum Insured
ICU Charges

Optima Secure

No restriction on ICU room rent

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

ICU-related cash benefits may be available under selected hospital cash benefits; limits depend on the policy certificate.

Advanced Treatments

Optima Secure

Information Unavailable

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

  1. Oral Chemotherapy 
  2. Robotic Surgeries 
  3. Stem Cell Therapy 
Co-payment

Optima Secure

Not available

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Co payment is applicable as chosen by the insured. 

It allows the insured to opt for 10% or 20% co-payment.

Disease-wise sublimits

Optima Secure

No

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Benefits are defined for specified infections and accident-related events; applicable limits are benefit-specific and should be confirmed in the policy certificate.

Restoration Benefit

Optima Secure

Yes, your sum insured restores to 100% once every policy year

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

No restoration benefit verified.

Cashless Healthcare Providers

Optima Secure

16000+ Healthcare Providers

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

10,000+ Healthcare Providers

Daycare Treatment

Optima Secure

Covers medical expenses for treatments not requiring 24-hour hospitalization, up to your annual sum insured

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Covers medical procedures requiring hospitalization for less than 24 hours, such as cataract surgery or chemotherapy​

Cumulative Bonus

Optima Secure

Your sum insured increases by 50% every year, maximum up to 300%

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

No cumulative bonus benefit verified. The published brochure lists a 5% renewal discount and a family discount of up to 7.5%.

AYUSH Treatment

Optima Secure

Covers AYUSH treatment expenses up to your annual sum insured during the policy period

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

.

Consumable Cover

Optima Secure

Yes

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Not specified.

Initial Waiting Period

Optima Secure

30 days

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

30 days for specific infectious disease and hospital daily cash benefits; 0 days for personal accident benefits, as stated in the published brochure.

Specific Waiting Period

Optima Secure

2 years

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

30 days for specific infectious disease benefits.

PED Waiting Period

Optima Secure

3 years

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Two-year pre-existing disease restriction specified for Hospital Daily Cash Benefit; applicability to other benefits must be checked in the policy wording.

Modern Treatment

Optima Secure

Hospital expenses for listed advanced treatments are covered up to your full sum insured during the policy period

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Not specified as a standalone benefit in the reviewed product information.

Annual Health Checkup

Optima Secure

Health check-up is available after the first policy year

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Not specified.

Pre-Hospitalisation

Optima Secure

You get cover for medical tests and doctor visits up to 60 days before hospitalisation, if your main claim is approved

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Accidental pre-hospitalisation expenses may be covered under the applicable accident benefit; a general time limit was not verified.

Post-Hospitalisation

Optima Secure

You get cover for medical bills up to 180 days after discharge, including physiotherapy if your doctor prescribes it

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Accidental pre- and post-hospitalisation expenses may be covered under the applicable accident benefit; a general post-hospitalisation limit was not verified.

Outpatient Department Cover (OPD Expense)

Optima Secure

OPD expense is not included

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

No general OPD benefit verified. Accident-related diagnostic tests may be covered under the applicable benefit.

Deductible Option

Optima Secure

Available as an option

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Any deductible or loss-sharing provision must be confirmed in the policy certificate.

Coverage Options

Optima Secure

Available coverage options: ₹5L, ₹10L, ₹15L, ₹20L, ₹25L, ₹50L, ₹1 Cr and ₹2 Cr

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Specific infectious disease benefits, personal accident benefits, hospital daily cash benefits and selected additional benefits.

Claim Settlement Ratio

Optima Secure

98%

VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

FY 2024-25: ~84%


Maternity Cover

Optima Secure

Not in base plan; available as paid add-on.


VS

Criti Shield Family Shield

Maternity and pregnancy-termination expenses are listed among exclusions.

Insurance Plans Comparison

Still Confused? Get Expert Advice

Our insurance experts are here to help you make the right choice. Get personalized recommendations based on your specific needs and budget.

Why Choose Our Expert Consultation?

End-to-End Support

End-to-End Support

From choosing the right policy to managing claims, every step is handled for you

Zero Spam. Zero Hassle

Zero Spam. Zero Hassle

Pure advice, no unwanted calls, no unnecessary push

Free Expert Consultation

Free Expert Consultation

Talk to experienced advisors at no cost, and make confident decisions

24/7 Claim Assistance

24/7 Claim Assistance

Get a dedicated expert managing your claim end-to-end, from hospital admission to approval, including dispute resolution and support

What Our Experts Help You With

Personalised Recommendations

  • Every suggestion is backed by expert analysis of your life stage, goals, and budget

Expert-Led Policy Review

  • We decode the fine print—identifying risks, sub-limits, and gaps you may have missed. No surprises later

Smart, Tech-Enabled Experience

  • From digital onboarding to real-time claim tracking, our platform makes insurance easy, accessible, and stress-free

Insurance Plans Comparison

Explore Insurance Category

Senior Citizen Health Plan

Senior Citizen Health Plan

  • Secure against age-related medical costs

  • Tailored for seniors healthcare needs

Most Popular

Family Health Plan

Family Health Plan

  • One policy covers the entire family

  • High sum insured with cashless care

  • Multiple coverage options based on your family needs

Maternity Health Plan

Maternity Health Plan

  • Covers delivery, newborn care, and maternity expenses

  • Reduces financial stress of childbirth costs

Insurance Plans Comparison

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Having questions? We've got answers. Explore our FAQs to find the information you need.

1-5 of 10 FAQs

Compare With Other Health Insurance Plans

Optima Secure vs Supreme Senior Premium

Optima Secure vs Energy Silver Without Copay

Optima Secure vs Ultimate

Optima Secure vs EquiCover

Optima Secure vs Optima Secure Global Plus

Criti Shield Family Shield vs Supreme Senior Premium

Criti Shield Family Shield vs Energy Silver Without Copay

Criti Shield Family Shield vs Ultimate

Criti Shield Family Shield vs EquiCover

Criti Shield Family Shield vs Optima Secure Global Plus

Oneassure

Health Insurance

Compare Health Insurance Plans

Optima Secure Vs Criti Shield Family Shield

Policy Pal

Chat with PolicyPal

Get a free policy review

No pressure. No product push. Just honest advice.