Claim Settlement Ratio vs Incurred Claim Ratio

Picture this - you’re choosing a health insurance plan. You’re comparing premiums, coverages, network hospitals, and discounts. But then you stumble across two confusing financial metrics - Claim Settlement Ratio(CSR) and Incurred Claim Ratio(ICR). You wonder - Which one matters? What do they really tell me? The truth is - both matter - each in its own way - and understanding them can make a big difference in picking an insurer you can trust.

In this blog, we’ll walk through -

1. What CSR is, what ICR is
2. Why they exist and why they matter
3. How they’re calculated in plain English
4. What good numbers are, and what warning numbers look like
5. How to use them in your decision-making
6. Some real-world scenarios
7. And finally a robust FAQ to answer all your lingering questions

Ready? Let’s roll.

What is the Claim Settlement Ratio(CSR) ?

Let’s start simply. The CSR is like a trust-meter - of all the claims that an insurer receives in a year, what percentage does it settle (i.e., approve and pay)?

In formula form -

CSR = (No. of Claims Settled ÷ No. of Claims Received) × 100

Example- Insurer A gets 1000 health claims during the year. Out of 1000 they settled 920. Then CSR= (920÷1000)×100= 92%

You want your insurer to settle claims, not just collect premiums.

But - and this is key - the CSR has limitations. It doesn’t tell you the value of claims, only the count of claims. It also doesn’t tell you how long it took to settle them.

What is the Incurred Claim Ratio(ICR) ?

Now let’s shift focus - ICR is more about the financial strength and payout behaviour of the insurer. It asks - of all the premium money collected, how much is being paid out as claims?

ICR = (Total Value of Claims Paid ÷ Total Premium Collected) × 100

Example - Insurer B collected ₹100 crores in premium during the year. They paid ₹88 crores in claims. Then ICR= (88÷100)×100= 88%

A good ICR indicates the insurer is honouring claims relative to premium and is financially stable. Neither wildly under-paying nor paying out so much that the business is unsustainable.

CSR vs ICR - A Clear Comparison

Let us line them up side-by-side so that you can see how they differ and where overlap -

So - CSR answers “If I make a claim, will they settle it?”. ICR answers “Is the insurer financially strong, paying out a fair number of claims relative to what they collect?”. You really need to check both.

Why Do These Ratios Exist - and Why Should You Care ?

From the insurer’s point of view, they exist because insurance is a business - they have to collect premiums and pay out claims in a balanced way. For you, the policyholder, they exist as a lens through which you can evaluate -

1. Will the insurer honour your claim when it matters? (CSR)
2. Is the insurer stable and credible, not one that cuts corners or will exit the market? (ICR)
3. Are you choosing an insurer with unrealistic numbers (that hide weak service or high exclusions)?

What’s a “Good” CSR and “Good” ICR ?

Here are general benchmarks (note - these can vary by insurer, year, business mix, etc) -

1. CSR - A healthy CSR is often above 90-95%. That means 90 to 95 out of 100 claims were settled. Anything much lower is a red flag.
2. ICR - Many experts suggest an ideal ICR range is 50-100% (with 70-90% often cited as “sweet spot”). Too high (100%+) - insurer is paying more in claims than it collects - may be under stress. Too low (<50%) - insurer collecting premium but paying fewer claim - may be rejecting lots.

'

Real-World Examples to Bring It Home

Let’s take a couple of scenarios.

1. Scenario 1 - Insurer C has CSR = 96%, ICR = 85%. For you - Great. They settle nearly all claims and pay out a strong portion of premiums as claims. This suggests reliability + financial health.
2. Scenario 2 - Insurer D has CSR = 88%, ICR = 105%. Meaning - only 88% claims by count are settled and the insurer pays out more in claims than premiums collected (105%). That could mean they’re under financial stress, may hike premiums or tighten exclusions soon.
3. Scenario 3 - Insurer E has CSR = 98%, ICR = 45%. On surface - they settle many claims - but only pay out a small part of premiums as claims. That suggests they might be paying only small claims, rejecting large ones or have many exclusions. So watch out.

The takeaway - Assess both numbers in context - not one alone.

How Should You Use CSR and ICR in Your Insurance Decision ?

Here’s a practical checklist -

1. Before you buy - Ask for the latest CSR and ICR for that insurer for health business (or if available, for the specific plan).
2. Check CSR - If CSR is low (<90%), you are risking claim rejections.
3. Check ICR - If ICR >100%, alerts of financial stress; if ICR <50%, maybe insurer pays too few claims. Aim for ~50-90%.
4. Look at trend - One year’s number only tells so much. If ICR has gone up massively (say, from 80% → 120%) or CSR dropped suddenly, dig deeper.
5. Complement with other factors - Claim settlement time, network hospitals, ease of cashless access, customer reviews.
6. Consider your plan type - For senior citizen health plans or special covers, numbers may differ - interpret accordingly.
7. Porting or renewing - If you’re renewing or shifting insurer, check how these ratios stack up for your new insurer and plan age.

Common Pitfalls & Misinterpretations

1. CSR doesn’t factor claim size - You might have high CSR yet many small claims settled and large claims rejected - so claims count isn’t everything.
2. ICR alone doesn’t guarantee good service - An insurer may show solid ICR but delay claims, reduce sum insured or impose heavy exclusions.
3. New insurers will have volatile ratios - If a company is young or collects low premiums, ICR may appear unusually high (claims > premiums) simply because business is small - so context matters.
4. Ratios are past data - They reflect previous financial years and may not account for future changes in business model, regulation or claim environment (e.g., pandemic effects).
5. Different plan segments - Health insurance is heterogeneous. Two plans from same insurer may have different risk profiles; their CSR/ICR may differ substantially.

The Final Word - What Really Matters for You

Let me speak plainly - When you buy health insurance, you’re buying trust. Trust that when you’re hospitalised, when bills pile up, when stress is high - you’re not alone. So picking the insurer isn’t just about cheaper premium - it’s about reliability, capacity, fairness.

CSR and ICR are two of your most powerful tools -

1. CSR tells you “Will they settle when I claim?”
2. ICR tells you “Are they likely to hold up when I need them?”

But neither tell you everything - so use them, but use them alongside other checks - plan terms, cover amount, network hospitals, customer service reviews and your own health/family needs.

In a sense - health insurance is like buying a safety net for the time when you fall. You want this net to be strong, well-anchored and tested. CSR and ICR help you inspect the net.

Explore Related Health Insurance Articles

Post Office Health Insurance Scheme I Star Health Insurance Reviews I ICICI Elevate Vs HDFC ERGO Optima I How To Surrender HDFC Life Policy I Top 10 Health Insurance Companies by Claim Ratio I Aditya Birla Health Insurance Reviews I Maternity Insurance Plans 3 Months Waiting I ICICI Elevate Vs Care Supreme I GIPSA Full Form I ICICI Lombard Health Insurance Reviews I Niva Bupa Vs HDFC ERGO I Best Dental Insurance In India